15 Best Store-Bought Ice Cream Bars, Ranked! 🍦🏆

There’s something undeniably magical about unwrapping an ice cream bar on a sweltering summer afternoon. The satisfying crack of chocolate coating gives way to cool, creamy goodness underneath and creates a moment of pure joy that’s hard to match. Whether you’re chasing down the neighborhood ice cream truck or scanning the freezer aisle at your local grocery store, that first bite of an ice cream bar instantly transports you back to carefree childhood days.

As someone who has dedicated countless summer evenings to testing frozen treats (purely for research purposes, of course), I’ve developed strong opinions about which store-bought ice cream bars truly deserve your hard-earned dollars and precious freezer space. This comprehensive ranking will guide you through the 15 absolute best ice cream bars you can find at your local supermarket.

You’ll discover options for every preference – from decadent chocolate-dipped classics to fruit-forward refreshers and even some surprisingly delicious health-conscious alternatives. Each recommendation has been thoroughly tested and evaluated based on flavor, texture, value, and that indefinable “wow factor” that separates merely good frozen treats from truly exceptional ones.

So grab a napkin (these can get messy!), and let’s dive into the wonderful world of ice cream bars!

How We Ranked These Ice Cream Bars

Before revealing our countdown, you should understand the methodology behind these rankings. Each ice cream bar was evaluated using the following criteria:

• Flavor complexity and balance: Does it deliver a satisfying taste with the proper balance of sweetness?
• Texture experience: How do the various components (coating, ice cream, mix-ins) work together?
• Quality of ingredients: Are premium ingredients used where it matters most?
• Value proposition: Does the eating experience justify the price point?
• Availability: Can most shoppers find this in their regular grocery stores?
• Nutritional considerations: While indulgence is expected, are there any noteworthy health benefits?
• Overall satisfaction: That special something that makes you reach for another one

Testing involved multiple samplings of each product by a panel of dessert enthusiasts with different preference profiles. While taste is subjective, this approach helped identify truly exceptional products that appeal to a wide range of palates.

Ice Cream Bar Nutritional Comparison

To help you make informed choices based on your dietary preferences, here’s a nutritional breakdown of our top contenders:

Note: Nutritional information is approximate and may vary slightly by product size and formulation.

Now, let’s count down the absolute best ice cream bars you can find in stores today!

#15: Nestlé Drumstick Classic Vanilla

The Nestlé Drumstick earns its spot on our list through a perfect combination of nostalgia and reliable satisfaction. While technically a cone rather than a bar, its portable nature and iconic status make it worthy of inclusion.

What Makes It Special:

• Classic sugar cone filled with creamy vanilla ice cream
• Chocolate coating sprinkled with crunchy peanut pieces
• There is a hidden chocolate “nugget” at the bottom of the cone
• Portion-controlled indulgence at a reasonable price point

The Drumstick Formula hasn’t changed much over the decades because it simply works. The contrast between the crunchy cone, smooth ice cream, and snappily chocolate coating creates textural magic that keeps fans coming back. The discovery of the chocolate-filled tip at the bottom of the cone provides a delightful finale to the eating experience.

Perfect for: Your nostalgic cravings and introducing a new generation to a classic frozen treat experience.

#14: Blue Bunny Load’d Cones

Blue Bunny takes the classic ice cream cone concept and cranks up the indulgence factor with their Load’d Cones line. These substantial treats offer serious value and flavor variety.

What Makes It Special:

• Exceptionally generous with mix-ins and toppings
• Available in numerous crowd-pleasing flavors
• Chocolate-lined cone prevents sogginess
• Substantial size offers satisfying portion

When you’re in the mood for a truly loaded ice cream experience, these cones deliver with ribbons of sauce, chunks of mix-ins, and plenty of toppings. The Bunny Tracks variety—featuring chocolate-covered peanuts, caramel, and fudge—stands out as a fan favorite that perfectly balances sweet and salty elements.

Perfect for: Satisfying serious dessert cravings when only an abundance of mix-ins will do.

#13: Klondike Original

When someone inquires, “What would you do for a Klondike bar?”—there’s a reason this iconic square treat inspires such devotion.

What Makes It Special:

• Thick, crackable chocolate coating
• Light, creamy vanilla ice cream center
• Distinctive square shape and packaging
• No-stick design creates a unique eating experience

The Klondike bar keeps things simple with its classic chocolate-vanilla combination but executes it nearly perfectly. The chocolate shell cracks satisfyingly with each bite, while the light ice cream provides the perfect creamy counterpoint. Its stick-free design creates a different eating ritual that many fans prefer over traditional bars.

Perfect for: Purists who appreciate straightforward frozen perfection without unnecessary bells and whistles.

#12: Good Humor Strawberry Shortcake Bar

This vibrant pink-and-white striped creation breaks away from chocolate-dominated competitors with its fruit-forward profile and unique coating.

What Makes It Special:

• Distinctive strawberry and vanilla cake coating
• Strawberry-and-vanilla ice cream interior
• Sweet cake crumbles provide exceptional texture
• Nostalgic appeal from ice cream truck memories

Good Humor’s Strawberry Shortcake Bar offers a completely different taste experience than most chocolate-enrobed options. The cake crumb-embedded coating creates a uniquely satisfying texture, while the strawberry flavor tastes authentically fruity rather than artificial. These bars transport many fans back to childhood ice cream truck purchases.

Perfect for: Those seeking fruity alternatives to chocolate-coated options or anyone who appreciates nostalgic treats.

#11: Outshine Fruit Bars

While technically not cream-based, Outshine’s fruit bars deserve recognition for excellence in the frozen bar category and provide a refreshing option when you want something lighter.

What Makes It Special:

• Real fruit as the primary ingredient
• Refreshing, cleaner alternative to dairy-based bars
• Broad flavor range, including exotic options
• Many varieties contain no added sugar

Outshine elevates the humble popsicle to gourmet status with its fruit bars, which feature real fruit and vibrant, authentic flavors. The Simply Indulgent line, dipped in chocolate, bridges the gap between fruit pops and traditional ice cream bars. The Strawberry variety offers particularly impressive real-fruit flavor.

Perfect for: Hot days when you want something refreshing rather than rich or as a lighter dessert option.

#10: Yasso Greek Yogurt Bars

Yasso revolutionized the frozen treat market by creating bars made with Greek yogurt that deliver genuine dessert satisfaction with improved nutritional profiles.

What Makes It Special:

• Higher protein content than traditional ice cream bars
• Probiotic benefits from Greek yogurt
• Lower fat content while maintaining creamy texture
• A wide variety of indulgent flavors

These bars prove that “better-for-you” frozen treats don’t have to sacrifice flavor or satisfaction. The Mint Chocolate Chip variety stands out with its refreshing mint base studded with chocolate chips, delivering an indulgent taste with about half the calories of premium ice cream bars. The slight tanginess from the Greek yogurt adds complexity that many tasters prefer to regular ice cream.

Perfect for: Health-conscious dessert lovers or anyone wanting to enjoy frozen treats more frequently without calorie overload.

#9: Magnum Double Caramel

Magnum elevates the humble ice cream bar to luxury status with its Double Caramel creation, featuring multiple layers of premium ingredients.

What Makes It Special:

• Two distinct layers of Belgian chocolate
• Gooey caramel layer between chocolate shells
• It has a velvety vanilla bean ice cream center
• Sophisticated flavor profile worthy of special occasions

Magnum’s Double Caramel bar creates an exceptional sensory experience with its layers of quality ingredients. The contrasting textures—crackling chocolate, flowing caramel, and smooth ice cream—create dessert complexity rarely found in a handheld format. The premium pricing reflects the quality of the ingredients, particularly the Belgian chocolate.

Perfect for: Treating yourself to a luxurious dessert experience or impressing guests with store-bought sophistication.

#8: Häagen-Dazs Vanilla & Almonds Bar

Häagen-Dazs brings its renowned ice cream quality to bar form with this elegant creation that emphasizes quality ingredients.

What Makes It Special:

• Super-premium ice cream with higher butterfat content
• Real Madagascar vanilla flavor
• Generous almond pieces embedded in milk chocolate coating
• Exceptional density and creaminess

What sets this bar apart is the extraordinary quality of the ice cream itself—dense, ultra-creamy, and richly flavored with real vanilla. The milk chocolate coating strikes the perfect sweet balance, while the almond pieces add pleasant texture and subtle nutty flavor. The simple ingredient list focuses on quality rather than novelty.

Perfect for: Ice cream purists who appreciate exceptional base ingredients and classic flavor combinations.

#7: Enlightened Keto Collection Bars

Enlightened has achieved something remarkable with its Keto Collection—creating ice cream bars that accommodate ketogenic diets while delivering genuine dessert satisfaction.

What Makes It Special:

• Keto-friendly with 1g net carbs per bar
• Zero added sugar formula using natural sweeteners
• Indulgent flavors despite dietary focus
• Satisfying fat content from cream and nut butters

For those following ketogenic or low-carb diets, these bars provide a legitimate dessert experience without compromising dietary goals. The Peanut Butter Chocolate flavor stands out with its creamy peanut butter ice cream base and chocolate coating, delivering rich flavor and satisfying texture with minimal impact on blood sugar.

Perfect for: Keto dieters or anyone monitoring sugar intake who still wants genuine frozen treat enjoyment.

#6: Chloe’s Fruit Pops

Chloe’s has created remarkably simple yet delicious fruit pops with clean ingredients and authentic flavors.

What Makes It Special:

• It has a clean ingredient list (just fruit, water, and organic cane sugar)
• Vegan-friendly formulation
• Authentic, bright fruit flavors
• Smooth, creamy texture despite dairy-free status

These bars prove that simplicity can create exceptional results when quality ingredients lead the way. The strawberry variety tastes like perfectly ripe summer berries, while the mango option captures tropical sweetness perfectly. These pops deliver sophisticated fruit flavors without artificial ingredients or unnecessary additives.

Perfect for: Clean eating enthusiasts, those with dairy restrictions, or anyone who appreciates uncomplicated fruit flavors.

#5: Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Fudge Brownie Pint Slices

Ben & Jerry’s successfully translated their iconic pint experience into a portable bar format with these indulgent chocolate treats.

What Makes It Special:

• Features the brand’s famous chunk-laden ice cream
• Generous brownie pieces throughout
• Dense, premium chocolate ice cream base
• Thick dark chocolate coating

These bars deliver everything fans love about Ben & Jerry’s pints in a convenient, portion-controlled format. The Chocolate Fudge Brownie variety stands out with its rich chocolate ice cream studded with chewy brownie pieces, all enrobed in dark chocolate. The high ratio of mix-ins to ice cream creates a satisfying dessert experience.

Perfect for: Ben & Jerry’s fans who want portability or portion control without sacrificing the full experience.

#4: Talenti Gelato Layers

While served in cups rather than on sticks, Talenti’s Gelato Layers deserve recognition for reinventing the single-serving frozen dessert concept.

What Makes It Special:

• Multiple components create a complex dessert experience
• Premium gelato base provides dense texture
• Sophisticated flavor combinations
• Visually appealing layered presentation

These ingenious cups feature layers of gelato, sauce, and crunchy mix-ins that create a multi-dimensional eating experience. The Salted Caramel Truffle variety stands out with its combination of sea salt caramel gelato, chocolate cookies, caramel sauce, and chocolate-covered truffles. Each spoonful can capture different layer combinations for varied taste experiences.

Perfect for: Dessert aficionados seeking complex flavor profiles and textural contrasts in a convenient format.

#3: Snickers Ice Cream Bar

This brilliant translation of the beloved candy bar into frozen form perfectly captures what makes Snickers special while enhancing it with cool, creamy ice cream.

What Makes It Special:

• Successfully replicates candy bar flavor profile
• Perfect balance of sweet and salty elements
• Multiple textures in each bite
• Satisfying nougat ice cream center

The Snickers Ice Cream Bar maintains everything fans love about the original candy—chocolate, caramel, peanuts, and nougat flavor—while adding refreshing ice cream. The frozen caramel achieves perfect chewiness while the peanuts maintain their crunch. This bar demonstrates how to successfully adapt a candy classic to a frozen form.

Perfect for: Snickers fans seeking a cooler treat option or anyone who appreciates sweet-salty flavor combinations.

#2: Klondike Heath Bar

Klondike elevates its classic formula by incorporating Heath toffee pieces into the chocolate coating, creating exceptional texture and flavor complexity.

What Makes It Special:

• Abundant toffee pieces throughout the coating
• Perfect marriage of chocolate and buttery toffee
• Additional crunch factor enhances eating experience
• Classic Klondike vanilla center balances rich coating

This variation on the classic Klondike formula demonstrates how one thoughtful addition—Heath toffee pieces—can transform a good ice cream bar into a great one. The buttery toffee notes complement the chocolate coating perfectly while adding textural interest with their delicate crunch. The generous distribution of toffee ensures flavor in every bite.

Perfect for: Toffee enthusiasts or anyone who appreciates textural contrast in frozen desserts.

#1: Magnum Double Sea Salt Caramel

Taking the crown as the ultimate store-bought ice cream bar, Magnum’s Double Sea Salt Caramel masterfully balances sweet and salty flavors with premium ingredients and textural complexity.

What Makes It Special:

• Perfect sweet-salty flavor balance
• Multiple layers of Belgian chocolate
• Rich sea salt caramel between chocolate layers
• Velvety Madagascar vanilla bean ice cream

This extraordinary bar represents the pinnacle of ice cream bar craftsmanship, featuring premium vanilla ice cream surrounded by sea salt caramel and two layers of Belgian chocolate. The sophisticated interplay of sweet and salty notes creates a flavor profile that appeals to mature palates while remaining universally crowd-pleasing. The multiple textural elements—cracking chocolate, flowing caramel, and creamy ice cream—create a dessert experience worthy of fine dining but available in your freezer.

Perfect for: Special treat occasions, impressing dessert connoisseurs, or whenever you deserve the absolute best ice cream bar experience.

How to Store Your Ice Cream Bars for Maximum Enjoyment

To ensure your ice cream bars maintain optimal quality:

• Temperature matters: Store at 0°F (-18°C) or colder for best texture
• Back of the freezer: Place bars in the back, not in the door where temperature fluctuates
• Original packaging: Keep bars in their original box for protection
• Avoid temperature abuse: Minimize time spent outside the freezer during serving
• First in, first out: Rotate your stock and enjoy older purchases first
• Optimal timeline: Consume within 2-3 months for best quality

“The perfect ice cream bar creates a moment of pure pleasure—the anticipation as you unwrap it, the satisfying crack of the coating, and that first creamy bite that makes you forget everything else for a moment.” – Artisanal Ice Cream Maker

Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Ice Cream Bar Match

The world of store-bought ice cream bars has evolved dramatically from simple chocolate-dipped vanilla treats. Today’s market offers incredible variety—from health-conscious options to super-premium indulgences—ensuring the perfect match for every preference and dietary need.

This ranking showcases the best options available now, but don’t be afraid to explore beyond these recommendations. Your perfect ice cream bar match depends on your personal preferences—whether you prioritize rich chocolate, fruity flavors, textural contrasts, or nutritional benefits.

Next time you browse the freezer aisle, consider trying something new from this list. You might discover a new favorite that brings back childhood nostalgia while satisfying your adult taste preferences. The humble ice cream bar continues to evolve, but its ability to deliver moments of pure joy remains constant.

FAQs About Ice Cream Bars

Q: How many calories are in the average ice cream bar? A: Calorie content in ice cream bars varies widely based on size and ingredients. Fruit bars and light options may contain as few as 80-100 calories, while premium chocolate-coated ice cream bars typically range from 250-350 calories. Check specific product packaging for accurate information.

Q: Are there any dairy-free ice cream bars available? A: Absolutely! The market for dairy-free ice cream bars has expanded significantly. Look for bars made with coconut milk, almond milk, oat milk, or fruit-only ingredients. Brands like Chloe’s, So Delicious, and Daiya offer excellent dairy-free alternatives that don’t compromise on taste or texture.

Q: What makes premium ice cream bars worth the higher price? A: Premium ice cream bars typically justify their higher price through better quality ingredients (real vanilla, Belgian chocolate, higher butterfat content), more complex formulations (multiple layers, premium mix-ins), and more sophisticated flavor profiles. These factors create a more satisfying eating experience and often deliver better texture and flavor intensity.

Q: How long do ice cream bars stay fresh in the freezer? A: Most ice cream bars maintain their best quality for about 2-3 months when stored properly at 0°F or below. While they remain safe to eat beyond this timeframe, they may develop freezer burn or texture changes. For optimal enjoyment, consume within the recommended timeframe and always keep bars well-wrapped.

Q: Are there any healthier ice cream bar options that taste good? A: Yes! Brands like Yasso (Greek yogurt-based), Enlightened (keto-friendly), and Chloe’s (fruit-based) have created delicious ice cream bars with improved nutritional profiles. These products offer genuine dessert satisfaction while providing benefits like lower calories, reduced sugar, higher protein, or cleaner ingredients.

Q: What are the most popular ice cream bar flavors nationwide? A: Vanilla ice cream with chocolate coating remains the most popular configuration nationwide, followed by varieties featuring caramel, cookies and cream, mint chocolate chip, and strawberry. Regional preferences exist, with some areas showing a stronger preference for fruit-based options or nutty varieties.

Ready to Upgrade Your Freezer Stash?

Don’t settle for mediocre frozen treats! Use this guide on your next shopping trip to select premium ice cream bars that deliver maximum enjoyment. Try starting with our top three recommendations and discover which flavor profile and texture combination speaks to your personal preferences.

Share your favorite ice cream bar discoveries in the comments below, or tag us on social media with your ice cream bar moments using #IceCreamBarBliss. We’d love to see which of these recommendations becomes your new favorite!

Git more recipes you might like

• Moose Tracks Ice Cream.
• Cold Brew Coffee.
• Best Chocolate Bar for You.
• Bread and Cheese Pairings.
• Cottage Cheese Cookie Dough.
• Kids’ Birthday Cake Designs.